Journal refuses to publish paper questioning Letby guilt over fears it might upset victims’ parents
Journal refuses to publish paper questioning Letby guilt over fears it might upset victims’ parents Reviewer of John O’Quigley’s analysis says it is not yet time for critique outside of the Thirlwall Inquiry 24 Lucy Letby is serving 14 whole-life sentences Credit : Cheshire Constabulary/PA Sarah Knapton Science Editor 27 December 2024 3:00pm GMT A statistical paper questioning the guilt of Lucy Letby has been refused publication by a science journal over fears that it might upset the parents of her victims. Prof John O’Quigley, from the department of statistical science at UCL, submitted an analysis to Medicine, Science and the Law, setting out the “logical and statistical errors” in cases of suspected serial killer nurses, including Letby. Although the police and prosecution said statistics were irrelevant in Letby’s case, Prof O’Quigley argued in the paper that “statistical arguments are used to show that a crime has taken place”. In the paper he stated that a...